How to Judge the Strength and Validity of Arguments - Practical Guide

Home » Essay Examples » How to Judge the Strength and Validity of Arguments - Practical Guide

Argumentation is an integral part of our existence. On one end, an argumentation may be to prove superiority over the viewpoint of others while on the other, it may just be for argument’s sake. But if well and truly pursued, argumentation can lead to a learning process where people gain knowledge from the other. So how does one gain anything out of this deal? If the argument is sound and has the necessary strength attached, then something productive can emerge out of it. Here are some ways you could judge whether or not an argument has some merit or you can ask others to write my essay.

  • First, the right argument would be made up of premises and a conclusion. Sounds very complex huh? Simply put, you have certain statements from which you draw a result. Consider the sentence “If it is snowing and it is a weekday then most probably schools would be closed”. The first two parts are part of the premise and the final is the deduced conclusion. There is absolutely no strength in just a conclusion unless there are premises to back it up. If you are confused, get help from an essay writing service now.
  • Now, the next step is to consider whether the statements made in an argument are of actual worth or not. Have there been any fallacies used? Or is it just a matter of genuine logic. This is a very important part because once you have valid support behind your statements then your conclusion could very well be true in an ideal scenario. From the above example, if past stats show that indeed snowy days do mean that schools are closed, then there is weightage behind the statement.
  • Do remember, fallacies tend to produce weak arguments. People may fall trap to these and try to convince others. Maybe many people support a certain notion so you also hop on the same mindset. Or there is not many conclusive data backing a statement and people also might try to use emotional means to prove their point. All this could be hard to ignore but these arguments would be very weak. Such practices are common in various types of arguments and need to be properly judged. If you have an assignment to judge some documents based on the argumentation being made, then an expert essay writer can point out if there is a sound basis behind it or not.
  • Lastly, even if an argument has no prior statistical foundation to back it up, then it must be testable to prove its worth. All the scientists that have produced wonders have always based their research upon facts and have proven them through experimentation. This is essential otherwise there would be no weightage behind what they say. The argument should appeal logically as well as with enough support so that people would have no trouble seeing what the person is trying to say. If you just one day get onto a platform and say ”Social media has led to an increase in socializing” it might be considered acceptable but not so much so. But if you make a statement that “According to an experiment conducted, these many people have found an increase in their social interactions” then immediately you have credibility.

Whether you are writing an argumentative essay, taking part in a debate, or simply hearing other people out, there is a chance that certain argumentation is taking place. You must be the judge of not yourself but others as well by thinking about what constitutes a solid argument. If you go in with the mindset of learning something, then the argument would definitely present many options to positively critique something. It is a matter of having the right intent.

These guides will help you understand different types of arguments. However, keep in mind, you can always consult a paper writing service to do it for you.

Exclusive access to the "EssayWriter" Learning Center. You’ll get weekly tips and tricks for improving your own writing and for achieving academic success through your writing.

About us

"EssayWriter" is the #1 Ranked Online home for great academic writing, essays, research papers, and graduate theses.

Why us?
  • 100+ subject matter experts.
  • 100% original writing (zero plagiarism, ever).
  • Short deadline service.
  • Love our work or don’t pay (satisfaction guaranteed).


Paper Due? Why Suffer?
That's our Job